Thrift store shopping can be a rewarding experience, offering everything from unique vintage finds to budget-friendly treasures. However, when it comes to decorating your bathroom, not all secondhand items are created equal. While thrifting can score you some fabulous pieces, designers caution that there are certain bathroom essentials you should always buy brand new for reasons of hygiene, longevity, and overall functionality.
Below, we dive into six key bathroom items that are best left on the thrift store shelves, with insights from three experts who know how to create a beautiful, functional bathroom.
- Shower Curtains: A No-Go for Thrifted Finds
A shower curtain may seem like a simple, inexpensive item to pick up from a thrift store, but designers advise against it, especially when it comes to used plastic or fabric curtains. Linette Dai, founder of Linette Dai Design, stresses the importance of investing in a high-quality, new shower curtain. “Plastic and fabric curtains are particularly prone to mold, mildew, and unpleasant odors,” she explains. These issues can quickly escalate, making your bathroom less inviting.
To achieve that spa-like atmosphere, Dai recommends opting for a fresh, high-quality linen or textured fabric curtain. “Pair it with a new liner to elevate the look of your space,” she suggests. Even with careful cleaning, experts recommend replacing shower curtains and liners every six months to a year to maintain hygiene and freshness.
- Lighting: Don’t Compromise on Brightness
When it comes to bathroom lighting, it’s essential to make sure your fixtures provide ample illumination. While it may be tempting to snag a vintage or bargain lighting fixture from a thrift store, Haley Bennett, co-founder of It Takes Two Vintage, warns against it. “Bathrooms require good lighting, and thrifted fixtures often come with quality issues,” she explains. “Low-quality, outdated fixtures that can’t be restored are commonly left behind, making them less than ideal for any modern space.”
Instead of relying on someone else’s discarded lighting, Bennett advises investing in new, energy-efficient lighting solutions. Whether it’s a sleek overhead fixture or sconces by the mirror, updated lighting can transform the bathroom and create the perfect ambiance for your daily routine.
- Rugs: Too Risky for Comfort
Rugs are an essential bathroom accessory that can make a significant difference in both comfort and style. But when it comes to purchasing secondhand bathroom rugs, Shelby Van Daley, founder of Daley Home, advises against it. “You never know where a thrifted rug has been,” she cautions. Rugs can often be challenging to clean thoroughly, and they may carry allergens or lingering odors from their previous home.
Beyond cleanliness concerns, Van Daley points out that some used bathroom rugs might be worn or faded, giving your space an outdated look. “A new rug will not only provide better comfort but also help maintain a fresh, inviting aesthetic,” she adds. Given how affordable new bathroom rugs can be, it’s worth purchasing a fresh one for a cleaner, more rejuvenating bathroom environment.
- Vintage Towels: Time to Let Go
While vintage finds can be charming, towels are one item you should skip buying secondhand. According to Bennett, secondhand towels may have already seen better days. “Used towels tend to show wear and tear, losing their absorbency and becoming less effective over time,” she explains. Since towels are a daily necessity, it’s best to purchase new ones for both comfort and practicality.
Fortunately, there’s no need to spend a fortune on new towels. Many stores offer affordable, high-quality options in a variety of styles and materials. By buying new towels, you’ll ensure your bathroom feels plush and inviting every time you step out of the shower.
- Toothbrush Holders and Soap Dispensers: Look for Fresh, Functional Designs
While vintage glass or ceramic containers can be tempting, Dai advises against buying secondhand toothbrush holders and soap dispensers. “These items may have hard-to-clean interiors, which can harbor lingering residue,” she says. Even if they seem clean, there’s always a risk of hidden germs or stains that are difficult to remove.
The best choice? Purchasing smooth ceramic or stone dispensers that are easy to maintain and will complement your bathroom’s decor. Fresh, new containers ensure that your hygiene products stay clean and functional while adding a modern touch to your space.
- Storage Bins: Choose New for Long-Term Organization
Storage is always a concern in the bathroom, where space is often limited. While secondhand plastic storage bins and trash cans may seem like a quick fix, Dai suggests buying new storage solutions instead. “Thrifted containers can have unseen grime, scratches, or even lingering odors,” she explains. “They might not be the best investment for long.
